|
There is a lot of posturing. A lot of group
shots of the X-Men looking like a group of
superheroes. A lot of exterior shots of the city
in Indonesia and
a lot of sad sack looks at the people around
this town filled with dead spaceships.
It's an intriguing idea and would be more so if
it hadn't been done before, but it has. And
Warren Ellis seems to be working on fumes here.
Seriously, check out the first collected edition
of his vastly underrated but nearly perfect
Counter X stories involving X-Force. It's so
much better than what is presented here, and
that was damn near 10 years ago with a lot more
editorial influence.
And I'll get to that in a bit.
So the X-guys find the man/mutant they were
looking for and locate him in a spaceship just
kind of docked and sitting in the sky. The
funniest thing comes from how they will get the
team up there. Storm mentions she can use the
winds to get them up there, but Wolverine is a
little too heavy. So Armor decides to, um, armor
up, and throws him. She comments how heavy he
is, and Wolverine says it's the adamantium and
Armor asks if he's sure it's not the beer. Then
throws him at a very very very fast speed in
which she worries she may have killed him. And
all Cyclops does is make her worry more. It's
cute, but it works. It makes Cyclops seem human,
which would have been great had the issue
stopped right there.
So Wolverine confronts the man/mutant with the
fire powers like every third mutant on the
planet and they tussle. The rest of X arrive and
confront him and he blows his own head up to
keep things secret. That's the gist.
Yet again, not a lot happens. Beast completely
vanishes from this issue, unless I'm completely
mistaken, but he is the star of the cover. He's
the only X-Man on the cover, and yet he's not in
the issue. AT ALL. Why the hell would they do
that? If I was a fan of Beast only and just
bought comics based on his appearances, I'd be
severely pissed. I don't as he's a character
that I can give or take, but come on, really? Is
it really that hard to whip up a cover with the
actual characters inside the book at the time of
the release? It's the same artist, you think
he'd know who was in the book. Whatever.
The art by Bianchi is all right. It's no John
Cassaday, but it'd be very hard to find a worthy
replacement artist to him. Almost completely
impossible, but the art is less muddy than
before. However, his panel placement is
ridiculous. There is no rhyme or reason to why
he's doing what he's doing, it's just a sense of
style that completely throws the book into a
loop. There are a number of occasions in this
issue alone where arrows would have made the
comic an easier read. Just to follow the panels
was a chore.
And then Ellis' script. The fact that the panel
placement makes no sense makes it dreadful, but
some of the ways Ellis has the characters talks
makes it so much worse. It's like if Grant
Morrison dropped a bunch of acid before writing
a comic, smoked crack, and then did Whippets
while driving an old beater car while typing the
comic on a round trip road trip with a
typewriter. The characters doesn't flow together
in a cogent fashion. From time to time talking
points correspond, but in others, it's like
we're dropped into the middle of a conversation
and we have no reason for that to happen as it
is supposed to be literal seconds after the last
panel. Unless the X-Men have all developed a new
sense/power of super speak than I don't know why
this is necessary.
Last gripe: get rid of Storm from this book.
Ellis is writing her in a completely stupid
fashion. She's being used as a moral compass
even though she has killed. She's being used to
question Cyclops' methods and new ideas on
killing if need be. He says he grew up, she says
he's different. And she still seems like a
valley girl that holds no sense of elegance as
she always did.
I'm at a loss with this comic. I want to give it
one final shot, but I don't think it's worth 3
more dollars. Unless something completely
awesome happens in the next issue, I think
Warren Ellis has lost a fan. His writing seems
to be completely idiotic and abrupt and almost
as if it were written by a 15 year old wannabe
pretentious prick. It's like he's trying to
sound smart with this comic when really it's
just coming off as hack. Ellis is this close to
joining Mark Millar on the hack list, right
alongside Frank Miller, Chris Claremont, John
Byrne, Bruce Jones, and Jeph Loeb. Getting
really really close Ellis.
|