|

Narrator: [quoting George
Orwell] "It's not a matter of whether the war is not real, or if it
is, Victory is not possible. The war is not meant to be won, it is meant
to be continuous. Hierarchical society is only possible on the basis of
poverty and ignorance. This new version is the past and no different
past can ever have existed. In principle the war effort is always
planned to keep society on the brink of starvation. The war is waged by
the ruling group against its own subjects and its object is not the
victory over either Eurasia or East Asia but to keep the very structure
of society intact."
On the brink of war, documentary director Michael Moore, a man whose
become synonymous with many labels depending on which political party
you belong to, creates his next outrageous documentary/ expose which
leans towards the left and
garnered many a controversy. Exposing the motives behind the
Iraq-American war from the United States, Moore manages to give a
disturbing and rather intriguing look at the intentions behind the war,
the intentions we were told, and what really happened while showing the
things the news never shows, the suffering of the families of the
soldiers, how
Iraq is suffering just as much and maybe more than we are during this
senseless conflict.
I've never been much of a fan of Moore; he's a manipulative opportunist
and "Bowling for Columbine" was a documentary with much potential that
trailed into different topics, but Moore hits the mark with "Fahrenheit
9/11". Yes, you may suspect what my political
leanings are by this review, and you may be right or wrong, but I won't
tell straight out, because I don't want it to cloud my feelings for this
movie. Whether or not this is a good documentary will not come into
play. Whether or not this is a good movie depends on whether you support
Bush or not.
Moore, who remained extra careful this time around hiring lawyers and a
large team of fact checkers paints a portrait of a man who wasn't fit
for presidency taking us to war because A) his family has ties to the
Bin Laden's so we went to war with the easy target Iraq, and B) because
he was an under-achiever attempting to live up to his father's career.
It's safe to assume Bush does not come off well here depicted as a
trigger happy cowboy, back stabbing worm, and a man incapable of running
an organization let alone a country running three oil countries to the
ground yet still remained an executive because of his connections.
Moore shows the footage right at the beginning of the documentary of
9/11 where Bush was
at a classroom reading with the students, he's told of the attack, and
he sits for seven minutes with a grim expression. Moore meanwhile
attempts to discover what was going through his head which looks a lot
like horror, confusion and shock that his job just became serious. Moore
manages to bring across an electric theme of tragedy, conspiracy and
satire through funny mock commercials, witty narration (Moore only
appears here in four short segments), and subtitles that undermine what
a politician might point out.
Meanwhile, he brings to the audience some insight on the government and
their ties to other corporations and the obvious tampering of the polls
to elect Bush to office, the government's dismissal of minorities who
insist Bush wasn't elected honestly, not to mention he points out the
government's method in instilling fear into American citizens in order
to control them and their tampering of documents and taking away of our
civil liberties in order to "protect us" from the bad terrorist men.
Protection doesn't come through control, it comes through cooperation,
something Moore states that the government is unwilling to abide by.
Moore shows a government that wants to control the country and used the
war as a stepping stone in doing so.
Moore gives some really brisk filmmaking while explaining many points of
the underlying themes of racism through recruiting as in cornering
people in low class neighborhoods
less like recruiters and more like car salesmen and we watch two
recruiters joking and laughing at minorities as they pass them and
declare them as marks giving them every reason why they should join even
telling one person that the marines could help with their music career.
Regardless of which political party you belong to, watch this
documentary
and become enlightened before you bash it or praise it. Moore doesn't
only criticize our government's sketchy handling of 9/11 but he also
manages to point out how insanely paranoid we are with one deputy in a
small town sending a spy to infiltrate a small peace group. They weren't
extremist hippies, just people like you and I who ate cookies and
discussed politics, not to mention Moore exposes a government that's
lost its priorities and bases its affairs more financially than what's
important to its citizens.
We've become a nation of people who fear and worry based on ridiculous
routines such as the color coded bar which is basically useless. Moore
does manage to reveal some interesting and astute points that, if you've
followed politics intensely, will ring true. Now, as for his statement
that the press is behind the government, I'd say they're more like that
kid in the school yard that follows anyone as long as it means he'll be
popular, they lean
anywhere because it's all about the ratings.
We also get to witness the suffering of people who really matter:
families of the soldiers who went to Iraq, and families from Iraq who
suffer everyday. We witness soldiers who were painted a pretty picture
of war and some whom approach the war like a video game in some rather
disturbing images, and realize they're really there for nothing and want
to go home. Moore paints a portrait of many layers as we watch a mother
suffering with the death of her son and appears at Washington to make
peace and cry but is greeted with ignorance from
witnesses. We see the usual shock footage Moore shows to bring across
his point with most recent videos of Iraqi horror and we have to wonder
if the violence was already there or did we just tempt them into
aggression?
Though, the ending gives no clear answer, it will bring about some sense
of enlightenment hopefully and this is one of Moore's better more
insightful documentaries in his career. The really good part of the DVD
features despite the contents that hilariously spoof the utter senseless
terrorist color meter, is the special ten minute segment profiling Arab
comedians who have their very own tour mocking the misery they've
encountered post 9/11. Though their misery during the last two years
regarding name calling and being profiled as terrorist threats are
horrible, they manage to make light of it with some very funny comedy,
and that makes them real survivors.
There were just so many
scenes during this that I felt were so strategically placed and out of
context to prove Moore's point including some scenes involving Bush and
some badly timed comments and jokes that, while not funny, seem to be
put to make him come out in a less than positive light to the audience
and it made me feel manipulated to buy what Moore was selling. Also,
Moore continues in his least subtle more outrageous method of getting to
his points by walking Capitol Hill and Washington asking senators to
enlist their children to the military and by renting an Ice Cream truck
reading the homeland security guidebook. Moore can get his points across
in less outlandish ways, but then it wouldn't be a Michael Moore
documentary if he didn't commit those acts, would it?
While much of the footage is
questionable and obviously placed out of context this is nonetheless a
gripping, heartbreaking, fascinating and engrossing documentary, and
regardless of your political standings I suggest you watch this. People
say Moore is Un-American for creating a documentary against the
president, well, it's Un-American not to explore other's views.

|