Buy This Film
2006
Rated: PG for adult language.
Genre: Documentary Drama
Directed By: Rupert Murray
Running Time: 1:28
Review by: Felix Vasquez Jr.
Review Date: 12/19/06
Special Features:
"Visualizing Memory: Making of…" featurette
"Where He Is Now" featurette
Interviews with friends
Extended interviews with experts
Q&A with the director and producer
Original Sand Dune sequence

UNKNOWN WHITE MALE

 

So this is what documentaries have become. Subjects fascinating enough to hold a movie, but still guided by directors who have to extinguish credibility in order to show off their artistic merits. “Unknown White Male” is almost essentially a reality show on film, and when I started this, I sat waiting for the film to progress. Then about almost thirty minutes in my sirens went off. I call these the “Bullshit Detectors” these are sirens that warn me when I’m being shit on, and “Unknown White Male” gave me this sense. About thirty minutes in I realized that about sixty percent of what you’ll see here is nothing but complete and utter straight faced bull shit.

“I got off at the next stop,” says Doug, “And I immediately found a police station.” Later, this is contradicted by a doctor who explains that Doug’s semantic memory—the memory that took his memory of snow, and basic facts away—had been diminished. So, one wonders, if Doug didn’t remember snow, how the hell did he know going to the police would be a safe decision? How did he know to get off the train?

 

Why wasn’t he surprised by much of what he owned in his apartment? Why did he become such a dick afterward? To say “Unknown White Male” feels disingenuous would be an understatement of the century. Everything about this film speaks of a group of people joining in on a large hoax. Doug has no memory of snow, yet can operate a video camera, which he lugs everywhere with him, which he documents every moment with.

He accepts that he lives in his basically lush apartment, yet never wonders who the dogs he owns belong to, nor does he really fear them. “Unknown White Male” is one giant jerk around, and I hate being jerked around, especially by a hackey director like Murray who seems to completely ignore logic in regards to the drama he tries to pass off as reality. And any sense of reality is undercut by the melodramatic effects and staged sequences the director inserts to explain to the audience that he’s an honest to goodness filmmaker. Then Doug’s re-discovery of life and society turns into a cheesy commentary about society and its endless running around which confuses the man with no basic memory; very subtle.

I guess it’s better for its audience to believe this is real, rather than honestly examine that there’s a good chance Murray and the crew are really just putting us on. We never find out what happened to him, and no one ever bothers to investigate beyond medical scenarios, not to mention we’re never given an explanation to how Doug’s mom died, and we’re provided with a staged sequence of him meeting his big sister for the first time which goes off without a hitch because “I just felt there was a connection.” Shit, someone call Mark Burnett, there’s a guy competing for staged reality here. Something must have happened, but they prefer not to tell us because it probably seemed arty at the time, and audiences often don’t challenge “complex” scenarios such as this.

In an ideal world, "Unknown White Male" would be a thought provoking and brutally gripping story of a man who suddenly lost his memory one day and had to rebuild his life. Instead, we have a manipulative reality show on screen with fabricated material, and that's pathetic... or not, I forget.

 

 

Have something to say about this review? Pop on over to Cinema-Lunatics
and speak your mind in our
Answer Back! Forums >>

 


[   Shop   |   Link to Us   |   FAQ   |   Top^   ]
All written reviews material and content are a copyright of Felix Vasquez Jr. and Cinema Crazed.
Content borrowed without written permission will not be permitted.

¤ ¤ ¤