Streaming Sundays: Orphan First Kill (2022)

In this prequel to 2009’s Orphan, we follow Esther’s origin story as she tricks a grieving family into believing she is their missing daughter. In true Esther fashion, she only has eyes for her new daddy family. Old habits die hard. Orphan: First Kill is now streaming on Paramount+.

Orphan: First Kill (2022) is a unique storyline that is pretty hard to see coming. If you saw the previous film, you know Esther’s M.O. She is a clinically insane adult woman in a child’s form, who preys on families. A con artist. A psycho murderer. That is the formula and this movie does not stray from that. Still, there is a point where this movie takes a sharp left turn leading to one of the more satisfying twists that we’ve seen in the genre as of late.

This film opens with a young woman joining the staff at a psychiatric facility where Esther (Isabelle Fuhrman) resides. Esther escapes the facility and works diligently to find her next family, before settling with the identity of a girl that went missing a few years prior in the United States. Claiming she was the kidnapped little girl, Esther is quickly accepted by the grieving family and travels to Darien, Connecticut with her new “mommy” to see the rest of the family. There is everything that you expect from an Orphan movie within the first thirty minutes. From there, this plot goes even more insane. As it turns out, the affluent Albright family matriarch, Tricia Albright (Julia Stiles), has quite a few grim secrets of her own that throw a wrench in Esther’s plans.

First Kill does a great job of coloring in a lot of the details we learned about Esther in the original 2009 movie – like Esther’s real name, for instance, is Leena. She took on the name, Esther, when she took on the identity of Esther Albright. As a result of trying to fight through the restraints at the hospital, Leena inflicted the lacerations on her neck and wrists that she hides with vintage accessories. We already understood the “daddy” obsession – she’s a grown woman with a disease that makes her look like a ten year-old, so her dating pool is nearly non-existent (with the exception of the weirdo from her stay at the hospital). Naturally, she gives all her affection to the man of the house, Allen Albright (Rossif Sutherland), but on top of that, we learn her trademark painting technique comes directly from her time spent with him.

What makes this Orphan movie creepy in new ways is still Esther. A clearly mature Fuhrman and her adult facial expressions translate Esther’s real age in a strange way. It is reminiscent of the facial expressions of Chucky versus the Good Guy doll – so unsettling. It’s the scary juxtaposition that we only got a tiny glimpse of in the first film when Esther was first revealed to be a grown-ass woman. In Orphan, the iconic make up removal scene revealed a much older face (with the help of prosthetics and makeup). This time around, Ether’s face is clearly more mature, but still passes as a child. Kudos to the production team on this film for deciding to keep Furhman on who is clearly not a child anymore. They rejected the latest de-aging CGI technology harshly used in films like The Irishman (2019) and instead opted for the practical route – 3 child body-doubles, creative camera angles, and optical illusions.

Orphan: First Kill is not only bat-shit wild, but extremely practical for such a tall order. You cannot help but respect it. When this project was first announced, there were so many questions around how the creators were possibly going to tell a story about a character that we already know so much about – and exactly where she is headed. Placing Esther in a family where they are not all that they appear to be was a welcome twist this time around. Story-wise, the Albright family – mainly Tricia and her homicidal teenager, Gunnar (Matthew Finlan) were the perfect antagonists to our anti-hero(?), Esther. Granted, we learn that nearly everyone is terrible in this story – with the exception of Allen – but when you compare the evil misdeeds of a ridiculously wealthy family to that of a woman stuck in a child’s body…? If there was any circumstance where we could see Esther as a victim, this was it.

You can watch Orphan: First Kill on Paramount+ and in select theaters.