Victorian Psycho [2026]

In Zachary Wigon’s underwhelming VICTORIAN PSYCHO, a new governess in 1850’s England is desperate to become part of her new household. Enough to kill her way there.

TW Child death

One would think Victorian Psycho, directed by Sanctuary’s Zachary Wigon, would be up my alley. A dark comedy of bloodletting and murder with an off-kilter protagonist, killing her way through the upper class in a slight message about the awfulness of the rich and class politics, led by Maika Monroe? Hell yes. Unfortunately, in execution, it stumbles on its own petticoats, impaling itself on the sharp axe of the concept.

Victorian Psycho started as a book by the film’s screenwriter, Virginia Feito, that I did enjoy, and I have read it twice. However, one criticism I had was “This feels as if it’s written to be optioned and adapted for the screen.” It read like a novelization for a film that didn’t exist yet. And now it does. And maybe it should have stayed a What If, because the finished product is an annoying, empty, lifeless affair that doesn’t capture what made the book so enjoyable, if slight. 

Maika Monroe plays Winnifred Notty (heh), the new governess to a pair of youngerters in the Ensor House, whose residents, the Pounds (father, mother, and two children), are of the stiff, rule-bound nobility and all the hypocrisies that come with it. Notty begins to Turn the Screw and cause strife in the household with her obvious mental maladies of mischief and murder, befriending the sweet and stupid nanny, Miss Snow.  The problem is, it’s dull. And empty, with little wit and spark. Frustrating as it is, it’s close. Victorian Psycho is a film that all too often coasts on the title, which clearly riffs on American Psycho (whether it’s the Bret Easton Ellis novel or Mary Harron’s film). That film had its themes of the emptiness of the Wall Street class of the Reagan’s 80s. This slightly deals with class issues, gender expectations, and the sheer hardness of the upper-class twits of the year. But more for jokes than statements, which could be fine if there was more bite to the dark satire that feels almost there. Heck, although it’s not a comedy, I couldn’t help but think of Marama doing just about all that Victorian Psycho does, but so much better on every level, including the horrific bloodletting. Hell, that has more, and gore isn’t the focus of that fine film (see it now). 

Maika Monroe tries desperately to give it oomph, but the material doesn’t give her role; it flattens her to a few notes. To refer to the referenced title, those moments where Bale’s Bateman pauses and does that eye thing as he revels in disgust. Monroe does this so often it becomes parody, along with the singsong that (purposely) doesn’t match her actions or real mindset. Sad, as she’s normally stealing it all with her special oddball charm in films like It Follows or Longlegs.  Sadly, it also wastes a further all-star cast; with each working on a different pitch, their performances clash. As the matriarch, His Dark Materials’s Ruth Wilson plays it straight; Jason Isaacs of Honey Bunch goes for camp. Hamnet breakout Jacobi Jupe and Wednesday’s Evie Templeton are given almost nothing to do. Templeton’s Druscilla almost has an arc but falls flat. Finally, Thomason MacKenzie tries her best as Miss Salt.

Director Zachary Wigon tries to enliven it with specialty camera work and methods. The camera swooshes around. It gets into tight spaces like a mouth and a keyhole; sometimes it turns upside down for… reasons. Wigon and cinematographer Nico Arguilar want so badly to replicate Barry Sonnenfeld and Owen Roizman’s work in The Addams Family it hurts. That fits the tone; Victorian Psycho thinks it’s more “ain’t I witty” with the particulars of the plot, nudge nudge, ya know.  The novel isn’t particularly deep either, but the biting nature of written unreliable narration is lost in translation (and so is Notty’s backstory), flattening the mood and joke. It amounts to having a thought-out sketch. The technical ends never feel more than a set with straight-from-the-closet costuming. Sorry to say it doesn’t live up to the title or the promises of bloodletting. Yes, people die (kids too), but basically it’s PG-13. Boo.

I’m sad Victorian Psycho was disappointing. I wish there was more to it, but sadly it keeps it underwhelming and perfunctory. As noted, I liked the book and wish I could say “the writer didn’t get why the book worked,” but the same person wrote both! With Monroe’s weaker performance and an overall lack across the board, I tell you to watch Marama instead. 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.