BOOTLEG FILES 836: “Here is Germany” (1945 propaganda film directed by Frank Capra).
LAST SEEN: On YouTube and other online sites.
AMERICAN HOME VIDEO: On public domain labels.
REASON FOR BOOTLEG STATUS: No copyright was ever filed on the film.
CHANCES OF SEEING A COMMERCIAL DVD RELEASE: Nope, it is doomed to public domain hell.
During World War II, the U.S. government churned out scores of nonfiction films aimed at both the enlisted military personnel and civilian audiences. Many highly regarded Hollywood filmmakers received commissions from the military and worked to create productions that would artistically drive the message about why the nation was at war and what it hoped to achieve.
In 1942, work began on a government-produced film called “Know Your Enemy: Germany,” which was designed to explain to American viewers how Germany evolved into the horrific Nazi regime. Filmmaker Ernst Lubitsch and playwright-novelist Bruno Frank worked on the project, but for unclear reasons production was halted and the film was shelved.
In 1945, as Allied forces were advancing across Europe, the unfinished “Know Your Enemy: Germany” was dusted off with the idea that it could be used to educate U.S. soldiers on what they could expect when they defeated and occupied Germany. Frank Capra took over the project as director and talented wordsmiths including William L. Shirer (who would later author “The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich”) and Oscar-nominated screenwriter Anthony Veiller began working on the production. But by the time the film was ready for release, Germany had already surrendered, thus forcing the “Know Your Enemy: Germany” title to be changed to “Here is Germany.”
While the war-weary U.S. soldiers of 1945 were not going to question the film’s contents,
“Here is Germany” offers today’s viewers a one-dimensional understanding of how Hitler came to power and why the German people embraced his lunacy. The film presents a significantly sketchy overview of German history with a propagandistic stereotyping of the entire German population.
The film opens with scenes of what is supposedly typical life in Germany, with uncredited narrator Walter Huston detailing how the average Germans – the farmers, police officers, housewives and postal carriers – appear to be no different from their American counterparts. Germany’s population is praised “educated,” “musical” and even “clean and tidy.”
But then, an uncredited Anthony Veiller takes over the narration to question how such nice people could create a war machine and go out of its way to torture and kill people. The film shows graphic footage from the liberated concentration camps of the starved-to-death prisoners laying in mass graves and the artwork created by the Nazi guards on skin canvases carved from those who were tortured to death. The film shows the massacre of Italians, Belgians and U.S. prisoners of war. While the film decries the Germans for burning churches, it significantly avoids mention of the German persecution of Europe’s Jewish and Romani populations.
What could fuel the German fury to such horrendous extremes? The film refers to a “Karl Schmidt” as the average German who finds himself swept up by generations of leaders focused on using military power to crush neighboring countries. From Frederick the Great in Prussia to Clausewitz to Bismarck to Kaiser Wilhelm II to Hitler, Germany is seen as being shaped by a succession of authority figures who saw their subjects as physically and intellectually superior to other cultures. The film also tartly observes that German history differed from American, British and French history with their respective focus on individual freedoms, and there is also a blanket blame on “the industrialists” who drove the nation’s economy into a military-industrial complex.
The film acknowledges that over two million Germans emigrated to the U.S. to get away from that environment – clearly, the U.S. government did not want to insist all German-Americans lacked loyalty (although that respect didn’t apply to Japanese-Americans during wartime). As for the ones who stayed in Germany, the film bluntly claimed that “those remaining were molded into mindless automatons.”
And that’s where contemporary viewing of “Here is Germany” runs away from the truth. The entire German population did not embrace Hitler and many Germans were either forced to escape into exile or were imprisoned for their opposition – most notably the anti-Nazi journalist Carl von Ossietzky, who was in a concentration camp when he was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for calling attention to the abuses of the Hitler regime. The level of German resistance to Nazism would not be properly documented until long after World War II ended.
“Here in Germany” wraps with the stated hope that an Allied occupation of Germany following its unconditional surrender, complete with new state officials to run the government, could offer salvation. It also cheered the idea of new textbooks of American authorship that would steer German youth away from the policies of the past. (Never mind that the U.S. was secretly moving Wernher von Braun and roughly 1,600 German war criminal scientists across the Atlantic to work on military aerospace projects – in the Pentagon’s mind, they were the good Nazis.)
To create “Here is Germany,” Capra and his collaborators harvested U.S. newsreel footage along with slices from “Triumph of the Will” and generous segments from historical German epics that were seized by U.S. occupation forces – if I am not mistaken, some scenes from the color extravaganza “Kolberg” are presented in this work in black-and-white prints. The German films were copyright protected, but the U.S. occupation force wasn’t focused on maintaining intellectual property rights at that time.
The 51-minute “Here is Germany” was released in October 1945, but it doesn’t seem to have been in official circulation for very long. A similar film with a much shorter running time, the 12-minute “Your Job in Germany,” was also being made available to U.S. military audiences around the same time and achieved the same anvil-subtle messaging much faster.
Because the films produced by the U.S. government during World War II were not registered for copyright protection, “Here is Germany” is a public domain work. While not as notable as other films of the genre, it has been included in wartime film anthologies on public domain labels. Perhaps the best copy of the film can be found on the National Archives YouTube page (see below). But unless you are eager to see as many World War II-era films as possible, “Here is Germany” should not be considered as a priority for viewing.
IMPORTANT NOTICE: While this weekly column acknowledges the presence of rare film and television productions through the so-called collector-to-collector market, this should not be seen as encouraging or condoning the unauthorized duplication and distribution of copyright-protected material, either through DVDs or Blu-ray discs or through postings on Internet video sites.
Listen to Phil Hall’s award-winning podcast “The Online Movie Show with Phil Hall” on SoundCloud and his radio show “Nutmeg Chatter” on WAPJ-FM in Torrington, Connecticut, with a new episode every Sunday. His new book “100 Years of Wall Street Crooks” is now in release through Bicep Books.